The Square Root of Summer

Book review by
Mary Cosola, Common Sense Media
The Square Root of Summer Book Poster Image
Physics and grief mix in sweet story of love and loss.

Parents say

No reviews yetAdd your rating

Kids say

age 10+
Based on 1 review

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Gottie mulls over quantum physics, explains it to friends, and discusses the topic with her teacher. Lots of physics and math equations. Many German phrases sprinkled throughout the book. Books mentioned include A Wrinkle in Time, The Time Machine, A Brief History of Time, and Forever.

Positive Messages

You probably have strengths other people can see in you but you can't see in yourself. Don't hide your problems from the people who care about you. Don't push away people who care about you. Love can be complicated, but you're usually better off having loved someone than to live without love at all. Live in the present; don't dwell in the past.

Positive Role Models & Representations

Grey, Gottie's grandfather, looms large in the book, even though he's been dead for a while when the book starts. He imparted many good life lessons and lots of love to Gottie and her family. Gottie's dad retreats into himself for most of the book, but he does reach out to his kids and improves their relationship. Ned is an art-school rocker who parties quite a bit, but he cares about Gottie and works to be a positive presence in her life. Gottie's friends and family show her how she hasn't been a good friend or family member to them over the past year, but they're still supportive of her.

Violence

First-person description of bad bike crash and injuries. References to an accident with a knife that sends a girl to the hospital, but nothing described or shown.

Sex

Lots of sexual and romantic longing. Kissing. Boy sleeps in girl's bed, and they make out a little, but it doesn't go far. Gottie recalls the boy she loved and the times they had sex, made out, were naked together, and had other intimate physical contact. The sex itself isn't described graphically but is mentioned frequently. Grandparent dispenses frank sex and birth control advice. Discussion of periods, pads, and tampons.

Language

Swearing is infrequent and not intense, usually exclamations more than swearing at people: "f--k" and its variations, "s--t," "Jesus," "balls," "bum," and "arsehole."

Consumerism

Brands and media mentioned infrequently and for scene setting or references: Band-Aid, Jell-O, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Scrabble, Connect Four, Marvel and DC comics, Adidas, Converse, and Facebook.

Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Drinking factors into the story at several points. Because the story's set in England, people drink at a younger age than is legal in the United States. Characters who are 19 or 20 drink and smoke; Gottie's brother come homes drunk at dawn frequently, throwing up in the bushes. A few references to his drinking increasing after his grandfather dies. Teens drink beer at a party and get tipsy and drunk. A dad drinks wine with his teenage kids, and they all get tipsy. A teen accidentally takes morphine, thinking it's a homeopathic pill.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know The Square Root of Summer is a coming-of-age novel about a smart, science-minded teen girl, Gottie, who's consumed with grief. Shortly after her grandfather dies and her secret boyfriend bails on her, she begins to notice odd shifts in time and space around her. A big part of the book is an "is it or isn't it real?" question around these weird happenings. Because Gottie's so into science, there are a lot of physics equations and discussions of quantum physics. Much of the book also deals with love and sexual longing. Even though sex isn't graphically depicted, Gottie often replays memories of her time with her former boyfriend, including sex and making out. Swearing is infrequent and is usually exclamations, including, "s--t," "f--k," and "balls." Older teen characters and adults drink, but the book is set in England, where the legal drinking age is younger. One character drinks to deal with his sadness.

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title.

Kid, 12 years old August 3, 2016

Fabulously written

i think kids 10 and over can read this becauase, we are going to end up learning about this, perhaps more educated on love could read it.

What's the story?

Margot Oppenheimer, or "Gottie," as she is known to those closest to her, feels surrounded and consumed by loss. Her mother died shortly after giving birth to her, her best friend suddenly moved away five years ago, her loving and hilarious hippie grandfather died last year, and her secret love took off shortly after her grandfather's death. As Gottie withdraws into herself, unable to deal with these problems, she starts to notice what she thinks are openings to black holes and wormholes, shifts in space and time. She occasionally finds herself back in time, reliving past experiences, returning hours later and someplace else. She's a science whiz who tries to figure out what's happening by using quantum physics theories, but it could all be a mental reaction to her grief. Her old friend and her boyfriend both return for the summer, stirring up lots of confusion and emotions in Gottie, which increases the number of odd time and space shifts around her. She realizes that by retreating into herself, she has lost important connections with family and friends. She needs to figure out how to go on living in the present and move forward when things go wrong.

Is it any good?

In this charming story, Gottie's life is consumed with grief, lost love, and quantum physics. Is she really seeing shifts in time and space, or is her grief-stricken mind playing tricks on her? With important losses piling up in her life, Gottie goes practically mute and retreats into herself. When she starts seeing static or blackness where the real world should be, Gottie steps into the abyss and relives past experiences. She delves deeply into quantum physics to explain these phenomena and lost time. The metaphor of grief as a black hole is a good one, as is the question of how much a person should revisit past events. These plot devices make the reader question whether what Gottie is experiencing is real, which is interesting but ultimately ends up a confused jumble at the end of the book.

Yet author Harriet Reuter Hapgood's writing is striking at times. She captures the way teens can be extremely sensitive and caring but also completely self-absorbed. Gottie's struggles with love and hurt are well conveyed. Her pain over being dumped and her confusion over whether her feelings for a childhood friend are reciprocated are beautifully rendered. Teens with an interest in romance will like this aspect of the book the most. The problem with Gottie as a main character and narrator is that she's so inside her own head, repeatedly going over the same events, that the story doesn't move forward enough. The reader gets stuck along with Gottie, which can be frustrating. This is an ambitious book, tackling grief, romance, family, friendships, and complex science, but it tries to cover too much in 304 pages.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about books and movies that use science (real or fake) as part of the plot. Do you think this makes them more interesting? Does it ever make the book or movie more confusing?

  • How do you feel about stories that leave the reader or viewer unsure of what's real or what's fantasy? Do you like the "is it or isn't it?" approach, or do you prefer stories to be more cut and dried?

  • In The Square Root of Summer, Gottie's strength is physics, and she dives deeper into it the sadder and more confused she gets. Do you have any school subjects or hobbies that you can disappear into? What do they offer to you that helps you?

Book details

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

For kids who love science and grief stories

Our editors recommend

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate