The Winner's Crime: The Winner's Trilogy, Book 2

Book review by
Carrie R. Wheadon, Common Sense Media
The Winner's Crime: The Winner's Trilogy, Book 2 Book Poster Image
More palace intrigue, less war in winning sequel.

Parents say

No reviews yetAdd your rating

Kids say

age 14+
Based on 2 reviews

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Battle strategy isn't discussed in as much detail as in the first book, but there's still talk about different types of warfare. In the author's note from Book 1, Rutkoski mentions a connection to the world created for the Winner's Trilogy and "the Greco-Roman period after Rome had conquered Greece and enslaved its population in the expected way of the time." For this book in particular, she read Herodotus' The Histories, which, she says, "gave me some ideas about how to represent the East."

Positive Messages

Star-crossed lovers are at the center of the series, leading to the question, what's stronger: a sense of loyalty to country, family, and way of life or the love of one person? 

Positive Role Models & Representations

Kestrel is at war with herself the whole book, not wanting to go against her father but disagreeing strongly with his politics. She feels personally responsible for the welfare of those fighting against her country and reconciles this guilt by spying for the enemy instead of outright opposing the emperor. Arin can be a bit hotheaded but acts bravely to protect his country, risking his life to form an alliance with another country. He also risks much for Kestrel.

Violence

A few people kill themselves in gruesome ways: by putting open wounds in a waste bucket and dying of infection, stabbing with one's own dagger as an "honor suicide," and stabbing oneself with scissors before soldiers can arrive. Besides the scissors death, there are two more deaths of sympathetic characters, one from a sword and the other in battle. Readers hear about all these deaths after the fact. A torture scene describes skin peeled off a man's fingers in front of Kestrel. Horses and people are poisoned. A face is slashed in a skirmish, requiring many stitches. A severe abdominal injury in battle is packed with gauze repeatedly. A kidnapping, a fistfight, a fight with a tiger -- men are injured and the tiger is killed. Repeated talk of an escaped slave's punishment: The ears and nose are cut off. And some talk of the death of parents years ago. A legend about a warrior girl kidnapped into a harem who kills her husband with knitting needles to the throat.

Sex

A couple of steamy kisses. Talk of unfaithful husbands and wives, a girl in a harem, and places in a fighting club where couples can have some privacy.

Language
Consumerism
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Kestrel is 17 and drinks wine at dinner with everyone else. A few tavern scenes, one with drunk sailors throwing up. Kestrel's former love interest -- who's a bit older than she is -- gets very drunk off wine and liquor. Tobacco pipes are smoked by bar patrons.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Marie Rutkoski's The Winner's Crime is the second in a planned fantasy trilogy, following The Winner's Curse. At the center are star-crossed lovers Kestrel and Arin, who have a few secret rendezvous with way more tension than kissing. Countries are at war with talk of horses and people poisoned or burned. Most of the action happens at court where a cruel emperor pulls the strings. People commit suicide rather than talking (one man is tortured first, the skin pulled off his fingers), and others are either injured or murdered with swords in the palace. A few characters close to Kestrel die. Far from the court a man is kidnapped and fights a tiger, with injuries. Kestrel, at 17, drinks wine with meals along with everyone else. A scene in a fighting club shows her slightly older friend drinking heavily. Throughout the story Kestrel battles with herself over what's more important: her ties to her father and country or her ties to Arin and what she believes is right. Unlike her war-happy countrymen, she feels responsible and guilty about those they kill and enslave in the name of expanding the empire. 

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title.

Teen, 16 years old Written byEva_Howser April 27, 2016

Absolutely Amazing!

Ok, to be honest, I'm not even done reading this book; in fact, I am nowhere near the end, and I'm already in love with this book and it's predec... Continue reading
Teen, 13 years old Written byjulie2003 October 31, 2016

Amazing!

Better than the last! It has more intrigue and suspense, but it was written beautifully. Not as much romance as the last book in terms of physical touch, but th... Continue reading

What's the story?

Kestrel is settling into palace life and her decision to marry the prince -- her bargain to save the country of Herran and Arin, its official governor now. Even though her wedding isn't until summertime, the emperor insists dignitaries start arriving in winter to celebrate with a number of balls. Arin, as governor, is expected to make the trip. Kestrel knows the rumors have been flying about their relationship but still awaits him breathlessly. It's not until Arin's face is slashed in a dark corner of a palace that she really understands just what lengths the emperor will go to to keep Kestrel as his obedient protégé. Some day she will rule with the same iron fist, conquering and enslaving to increase the empire. It would all be perfectly laid out for her ... if her loyalty to Arin and fear for the Herrani people didn't lead her to spy on her own court. 

Is it any good?

There's something to this formula for star-crossed lovers: The harder it is for them to be together, the more gripping the love story. In THE WINNER'S CRIME, it's hard to think of a worse situation for Arin and Kestral. Each one of their rendezvous is fraught with tension, especially the last one. The climactic scene is perfectly laid out in clues throughout the novel with the secret room and Kestral's father's watch. Well played. 

Occasionally pieces of the story don't fit together quite as neatly -- it takes too long to get to the connection between the dress and the water engineer. And sometimes there are a few too many coincidences, such as Arin's connection to just the right escaped slave. But it all serves to tell the story of a very unlucky couple whom readers will still desperately be rooting for in the final installment.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about the series so far. The first book, The Winner's Curse, ended with a cliffhanger and so does this one. What do you think is in store for Kestrel and Arin?

  • Why do you think so many fantasy stories are published as trilogies? What about the genre inspires that approach? 

  • What are Kestrel's motivations to spy on the empire? Would you have done that in her place? What are her other options if she fears for her life? Does she have any?

Book details

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

For kids who love fantasy

Our editors recommend

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate