Wishtree

Book review by
Jan Carr, Common Sense Media
Wishtree Book Poster Image
Parents recommend
Moving, gentle friendship story tackles anti-Muslim bigotry.

Parents say

age 8+
Based on 7 reviews

Kids say

age 8+
Based on 6 reviews

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Lots of factual information about trees and animals (e.g., tree rings tell age, hollows may be caused by woodpeckers or fallen branches, trees house animal families, crows use tools and mimic sounds, meaning of "scaffold branch" and "crepuscular"). Names of groups of animals, like a charm of hummingbirds, a murder of crows. Irish tradition of wishing tree. Includes many fresh examples of metaphors.

Positive Messages

Though hate exists, human connection and love is strong and can counteract it. Friends can disagree and still like each other. Diverse communities are "wild and tangled and colorful. Like the best kind of garden."

Positive Role Models & Representations

The tree enlists the help of animals to help Samar find a friend. Stephen becomes Samar's friend even though his parents disapprove. The community rallies to support Samar and her family and help them feel welcome. The tree's animal friends rush to support it when it's threatened.

Violence & Scariness

Someone throws eggs at Samar's house. A passing car of angry men shout "Muslims, get out!" A boy carves "LEAVE" on the tree in Samar's yard.

Language

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Wishtree is by Newbery Award winner Katherine Applegate (The One and Only Ivan), who brings her trademark sensitivity and humor to a thorny, topical subject. The central conflict is an instance of hate aimed at a Muslim family -- a boy carves the word "LEAVE" into their tree -- but Applegate handles the incident gently. We never meet the boy who did it, and the community uses the opportunity to express welcome for the family. Applegate has crafted this as a sweet friendship story and laced it with factual information about trees and animals. The story, narrated by a talking tree, also has talking animals, short chapters, and sweet black-and-white illustrations scattered throughout, making it a perfect choice for young readers.

Wondering if Wishtree is OK for your kids?

Set preferences and get age-appropriate recommendations with Common Sense Media Plus. Join now

Continue reading Show less

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Adult Written byAflower2 April 15, 2019

Nice story

It is a nice story. I think a child older than 8 will be bored.
Parent of a 6, 6, and 8-year-old Written byRobvansimon August 26, 2019
Kid, 8 years old April 7, 2018

Sad, but good

All of Katherine Applegate's books are slightly sad. No, that's an understatement. But the books are really good. Wishtree is about a tree (it is the... Continue reading
Kid, 9 years old January 13, 2020

Good

It is a good book I had to read it over the summer and it was good red and bongo are good characters positive messages

What's the story?

WISHTREE is narrated by a stately oak tree, Red, which keeps watch over a community of modest homes and diverse families. Red's seen a lot in the 216 years it's been alive, and is now inhabited by a host of animal families, whom we hear conversing. Red is nicknamed "the wishtree" because once a year, people come and tie wishes to its branches, including young Samar, who often visits Red and wishes she had a friend. Conflict is stirred when a strange boy carves the word "LEAVE" into the tree bark, targeting Samar's Muslim family. Also, the woman who owns the property threatens to cut down Red, since the tree's roots are interfering with the plumbing. Will the neighbors support Samar and her family? Will Samar make a friend? Can Red be spared?

Is it any good?

There's a charming whimsy to this quiet friendship book that touches on bigotry but draws on the deeper wisdom of the stately oak tree that narrates the story of its richly diverse community. Author Katherine Applegate often untangles thorny subjects for young readers, in the past addressing captive animals and homelessness. In Wishtree, she takes on anti-Muslim bigotry, handling the subject with a light touch, so the treatment doesn't feel heavy. There's sly humor, and fun friendships involving the tree, talking animals, and humans, mixed in with some meaty scientific information about trees and animals. Applegate, a lovely writer, sprinkles the story with language that's strikingly beautiful but never showy. For instance, a sky's described as "freckled with stars," a crow’s eyes are "like morning blackberries, dark and dewy," and a night sky displays a "splinter of moon."

Like many beloved kids' novels, this one is enhanced with illustration, and readers will be charmed by the black-and-white drawings by Charles Santoso (Ida, Always) scattered throughout. If, like the tree, we're sometimes baffled by angry human behavior and ugly conflict, this story's a balm, promoting acceptance and empathy, and full of quiet wisdom and soothing pleasures.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about the instance of prejudice that happens in Wishtree. Why do you think the boy carved "LEAVE" into the tree? Have you noticed any bigotry in your community? How did people respond?

  • What factual information about trees and animals did you learn from this story? Did any surprise you?

  • If you had a wishtree in your yard or neighborhood, what would you wish for?

Book details

Our editors recommend

For kids who love stories of empathy and Muslim characters

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality.

Learn how we rate