Common Sense Media Review
Thoughtful docu about model government club for teens.
Parents Need to Know
Why Age 10+?
Any Positive Content?
Where to Watch
Videos and Photos
The Youth Governor
Parent and Kid Reviews
What's the Story?
THE YOUTH GOVERNOR is a documentary about Youth & Government (YNG), an extracurricular model legislature program sponsored by schools through local YMCAs. YNG allows high school students to participate in a state-wide mock government. Although every state has their own delegation, this film follows the California chapter -- which consists of about 4,000 students -- in the 2018–19 cycle as they vote for a governor. From dozens of candidates, the election process narrows the field to six, then three, and eventually two. Brothers/filmmakers Matthew and Jaron Halmy follow the finalists on the campaign trail as they, like adult candidates, form alliances, listen to strong minority voting blocs (this being California, that means conservative-leaning students), and give stump speeches. There's even a minor campaign scandal: A candidate's old video supporting an unpopular policy suspiciously resurfaces. As the candidates prepare for the final election, the directors delve into the teens' lives at home and at school.
Is It Any Good?
This film is an interesting, educational look at how students learn the political process through a long-respected organization that teaches teens about running a campaign -- and a state. As one of the adult mentors (who was himself a former California youth governor) explains, participating in YNG -- particularly at the level of an election candidate -- can transform a life. The directors don't explore all facets of YNG, focusing primarily on the gubernatorial race and election. A clear early frontrunner is Aidan Blain, an athlete from Santa Monica who knows how to work a room. His competition includes Piper Samuels, who's from a more politically moderate group and tries to work with a conservative adviser who doesn't want traditionally liberal candidates to forget about the "vocal minority." There's also Bayo Collins, who's from Long Beach and is excited to make his family proud by running for the top job.
Although The Youth Governor doesn't quite offer the pathos or emotional investment of Boys State or Try Harder!, it does shine a light on a venerable organization that provides students with a memorable firsthand experience of how a state's political structure works. The Halmys zero in on some of the more unseemly aspects of the election cycle, like when Piper discovers that antisemitic and misogynistic comments are being made about her (with even uglier plans being made in the event of her victory). Without spoiling the documentary, it's refreshing to see who's willing to help her take down the bigoted bullies. Piper is also open about how being a girl affects how she's perceived and limits her behavior. Meanwhile, Bayo's social media issues reveal how easily the voting public can turn away from an otherwise charismatic candidate. All it takes is one well-timed leak, and poll numbers will suffer. The documentary doesn't judge any of the candidates for how they campaign or what potentially false promises they make. There are no villains or heroes in this film; either of the final two candidates is a viable governor. Perhaps that's why, in the end, the announcement of the winner is slightly anticlimactic: Audiences aren't pushed to root for an obvious favorite. You'll be proud of them all.
Talk to Your Kids About ...
Families can talk about what happens when politics become divisive. Which of the candidates in The Youth Governor was able to bring people with diverse viewpoints together? Why is it important for people with opposing ideas to be able to work together?
Why does Piper say that she can't be as high energy as Aidan? How are men and women in politics perceived and treated differently?
How does being Jewish affect one of the candidates? In what ways do the prejudice and antisemitism directed at her mirror the fringes of contemporary politics? Discuss how adult politicians have made discriminatory remarks. What happened to them?
Why should students learn how state politics and democracy work? How would that knowledge help students become more involved citizens?
What character strengths did you notice the featured students demonstrating?
Movie Details
- In theaters : August 26, 2022
- On DVD or streaming : August 26, 2022
- Directors : Jaron Halmy , Matthew Halmy
- Studio : Greenwich Entertainment
- Genre : Documentary
- Character Strengths : Communication , Empathy , Integrity , Teamwork
- Run time : 86 minutes
- MPAA rating :
- Last updated : September 9, 2022
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by
Suggest an Update
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.
See how we rate
