Parents' Guide to Are You Afraid of the Dark?

TV Nickelodeon Drama 2019
Are You Afraid of the Dark? Poster Image

Common Sense Media Review

Emily Ashby By Emily Ashby , based on child development research. How do we rate?

age 11+

Horror series reboot thrills with tense, frightful story.

Parents Need to Know

Why Age 11+?

Any Positive Content?

Parent and Kid Reviews

age 11+

Based on 7 parent reviews

age 11+

Based on 12 kid reviews

Kids say that the show offers a balance between creepiness and mild scares, making it suitable for older children but potentially too intense for younger ones; however, some reviewers found it less frightening than expected. The storytelling features elements of teamwork and avoids inappropriate content, appealing to family viewing, although it includes mild violence and moments that could be disturbing for very young viewers.

  • creepy elements
  • suitable for family
  • mild violence
  • not very scary
  • teamwork focus
Summarized with AI

What's the Story?

In ARE YOU AFRAID OF THE DARK?, Rachel Carpenter (Lyliana Wray) starts the year at a new high school and quickly resigns herself to life as a social outsider. But when some classmates notice her interest in the horror genre, she earns an invite to the mysterious Midnight Society, a selective group that share their love of scary stories around a campfire in the middle of the night. After Rachel uses her recurring nightmares to create a story of her own and earns a place in the club, the five friends are shocked to discover that the dream starts coming true in their own town. Suddenly Rachel, Gavin (Sam Ashe Arnold), Akiko (Miya Cech), Graham (Jeremy Ray Taylor), and Louise (Tamara Smart) are thrust into a mystery that's all very real ... or is it?

Is It Any Good?

Our review:
Parents say ( 7 ):
Kids say ( 12 ):

This self-contained three-part series is shivery, quivery fun for tweens and teens who like scares. Viewers are introduced to Rachel, a thoroughly sympathetic new kid in town who doesn't make acquaintances easily but falls into a group of like-minded horror fans and discovers the kind of friendships she's longed for. Unfortunately her happiness is short-lived, as the Midnight Society members threaten to turn on her when she can't explain how her nightmares wind up threatening their town in a very real way. As they attempt to solve the mystery and get drawn into the fearsome happenings, Rachel becomes more concerned with keeping her friends alive than with keeping her friendships going.

Are You Afraid of the Dark? takes a refreshing stance on the diversity of the characters; both boys and girls are represented, and there are notable racial and social status differences among them, all of which reminds viewers that people can relate to each other on various levels despite what separates them. It also does a good job escalating the fear without actual violence. Most of what scares here is the power of suggestion, the hint of the unexplained, and the characters' visceral reactions to what they see and hear. Depending on your tweens' sensitivities, this may make it a slightly safer option than a show with more physical violence. Ultimately it's a real know-your-kid scenario; the scares are real, so knowing up front whether these kind of scares will affect yours is the key.

Talk to Your Kids About ...

  • Families can talk about fear and its effects in real life. Kids: What kinds of things scare you? Are these tangible or imaginary fears? How do you take control of your fears so that they don't control you?

  • In what ways do the characters' friendships in Are You Afraid of the Dark? challenge stereotypes? Have you ever found a friend in an unlikely place? What qualities -- like honesty or compassion -- do you look for in friends?

  • Do your tweens find this series scary? Does its lack of physical violence work for or against its ability to scare viewers? Is it fun to be scared by what you watch?

TV Details

Did we miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by

Are You Afraid of the Dark? Poster Image

What to Watch Next

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate