Miss Scarlet and the Duke

TV review by
Joyce Slaton, Common Sense Media
Miss Scarlet and the Duke TV Poster Image
Violence is diluted in female-centered period mystery.

Parents say

age 13+
Based on 1 review

Kids say

age 13+
Based on 3 reviews

Did we miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this TV show.

Positive Messages

This show rewards courage and integrity, with the answers to mysteries appearing to those who keep their promises and care enough to keep working for solutions. 

Positive Role Models

Eliza Scarlet is a strong and independent women in an era where she's implicitly instructed not to be. Characters say things like "If a lady must walk [outside] she should be in the company of a gentleman to protect her," which Scarlet disregards airily. William Wellington is a more typical Victorian-era man, with views about what women should and should not do, though he bears a grudging respect for Scarlet's fearlessness and perseverance. 

Violence

This series revolves around crime, which is sometimes violent, including murder. However, violence is soft-pedaled -- if we see dead bodies, they generally appear to be peacefully sleeping or the visuals are minimized, like when we see a man with his throat slit in a small black and white photo. We do see some blood, like on a murder weapon, but we don't see any gore or people actually being hurt. Many of Scarlet's cases are centered around non-violent mysteries as well. She is frequently in danger, such as in a scene when she visits a dancehall and threatens to burn the place down with a candle and bottle of turpentine (she doesn't). 

Sex

There's sexual tension between Eliza and William; expect them to flirt and kiss. Scarlet occasionally uses her sexuality to pry information from subjects, like when she tells a subject that she can "show you what us skinny girls can do" while sidling up flirtily and then handcuffing him to a bed. Vintage terms for sexworkers are heard and include "whore," "whoremonger." 

Language

Language is very infrequent, and consists of "damn." Vintage terms that insult women and sex workers are heard, such as "whore," "whoremonger," and "tart." 

Consumerism
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Characters drink at dinners, occasions, and to toast one another. Some drink to the point where they damage their reputations and business. In a few scenes, background characters are seen drunk and passed out. 

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Miss Scarlet and the Duke is a mystery series starring a female Victorian-era detective during an era when a women's "place" was said to be in the home. Though the series revolves around criminal cases, some of which are violent to the point of murder, violence is rather minimal. We see a few dead bodies but they look to be peacefully sleeping or gore/blood is otherwise not present. For instance, we see a dead body with a slit throat in a small black and white photo. Some cases don't even involve violence but instead deception and mistaken identity. Main character Eliza Scarlet sometimes uses her sexuality to escape moments in peril, like when she implies she'll have sex with a man to get information. She is often in mortal danger, such as a scene in which she's trapped yet threatens to burn the place down by pouring turpentine on a candle. Eliza's rival police Inspector William Wellington is her love interest; expect flirting, romance, kissing. Cursing is infrequent ("damn") but vulgar words for women and sex workers are used, including "whore," "tart," "whoremonger." Characters drink at dinners and get-togethers; some characters are said to have drinking problems that damage their relationships and reputation. Eliza Scarlet is a proto-feminist and a strong, confident character whose courage and integrity is rewarded with work she enjoys and is good at, despite the people in her life and society in general telling her she shouldn't be a detective at all. 

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Parent of a 15 and 17-year-old Written byMichelle T. August 26, 2021

Fun with a great female role model

My family (husband, daughter who is 15 and son who is 17 as well as grandma) all really enjoyed this series! The acting is good, the stories are engaging and M... Continue reading
Teen, 15 years old Written byClaireF05 March 14, 2021

Disappointing for a PBS masterpiece show

The entire first episode is about whores in a whorehouse.
Teen, 13 years old Written byBobtheminion07 February 8, 2021
There are some inferences and not to much language. I love this show and I've only watched a few episodes so there might be things in other other things i... Continue reading

What's the story?

MISS SCARLET AND THE DUKE is set in England in the late 19th century, where Eliza Scarlet (Peaky Blinders' Kate Phillips) longs to be a police detective in an era when women were expected to be wives and mothers, end of list. But when a combination of fate and ambition launches her fledgling career as a private detective, Scarlet finds ways to use her gender to bend society's rules to her will. Watching her with frustration (and more than a little awe) is Police Chief Inspector William Wellington (Stuart Martin), Eliza's childhood friend, who despairs of the danger she's getting into by investigating cases of murder and mayhem. 

Is it any good?

Kate Phillips makes an charming brimming-with-confidence Miss Scarlet and the vintage feminist setup is fun, but this drama is less colorful and more predictable than one would hope. Victorian-era London looks like it's composed entirely of three hues -- black, gray, and dirty dark blue -- and though viewers will relish period touches like horses clip-clopping down the streets and men shaving with straight razors, it just looks grim. A mystery seems like just the thing to liven things up, but since the show's cases generally seem to feature an obvious villain that Scarlet must unmask with a combination of fearlessness and intelligence, dramatic tension is light. 

And so Miss Scarlet and the Duke winds up primarily getting what verve it has from the interplay between Scarlet and her childhood friend, Chief Inspector William Wellington. The moments in which Scarlet as a feisty proto-feminist subverts the extremely patriarchal maneuverings of Wellington -- who's forever infuriated by her shenanigans -- are the best in the series. The two have obvious chemistry and are enjoyable as perpetually dueling rivals. The scenes in which Scarlet's grit runs headlong into Victorian sensibilities are also fun, like when her cook and maid are simply aghast that Scarlet wants to go out sleuthing late in the afternoon. "What will people think of a woman who goes out alone after dark?" they ask. "Let them think what they like," Scarlet shrugs. In such scenes, this series is a delight. It does drag a wee bit in between bright spots, but viewers who like a gentle period mystery could do worse. 

Talk to your kids about ...

  • TV shows about crime either focus on the violence of the acts or take care to make the violence less upsetting. Which approach does Miss Scarlet and the Duke take? How does it make death and danger seem less upsetting and immediate? 

  • Each week, the characters on Miss Scarlet and the Duke solve a different criminal case. Can you name any other shows with this "case of the week" structure? Why do you think people enjoy this style of show? 

  • How does Eliza Scarlet show courage, and integrity? Why are these important character strengths

TV details

Our editors recommend

For kids who love mysteries

Character Strengths

Find more TV shows that help kids build character.

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

Streaming options powered by JustWatch

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality.

Learn how we rate